Almost everyone has hidden a spare key at some point, and almost everyone has hidden it in one of the same half-dozen spots. That is the problem. The hiding places that feel clever to us are the first places anyone looking for a key will check, because they are the places everybody uses. A spare key is a genuinely useful thing to have, but a badly managed one is just an unlocked door waiting to be found. This guide covers the hiding spots to abandon, the smarter alternatives, and what to do when a spare goes missing.
Locksmith On Time helps Ottawa homeowners rethink their spare-key habits all the time, usually after a near-miss made them realize the fake rock was not fooling anyone.
The Hiding Spots to Stop Using
If your spare lives in any of these, assume it is findable.
- Under the doormat or a nearby flowerpot. The most checked spots in existence. A few seconds of looking finds them.
- On top of the door frame or ledge. Predictable and easy to sweep a hand across.
- Inside a fake rock or fake sprinkler. These products are so common they are instantly recognizable, often standing out as the one object that does not match the rest of the yard.
- Taped inside the mailbox or under the step. Convenient for you, convenient for anyone else.
The underlying issue is that any outdoor hiding spot trades your security for your convenience. If it is easy enough for you to grab in a hurry, it is easy enough to find.
Why This Matters More Than It Seems
A found spare key is worse than a forced entry in one important way: it leaves no trace. Someone can enter, leave, and come back, and you may never know the key was ever discovered. That is why the goal is not a cleverer hiding spot. It is to stop relying on a hidden physical key at all.
Smarter Ways to Handle Access
The good news is that the alternatives are both safer and more convenient than a key under the mat.
Give a Spare to a Trusted Person
The simplest upgrade is to hand your spare to a neighbour, friend, or family member you trust rather than hiding it outside. The key is never exposed, and you still have a fallback if you get locked out.
Use a Proper Lockbox
A quality, tamper-resistant lockbox mounted securely, with a code you control, is far better than any yard hiding spot. The key stays contained, and you can change who has the code. This is a common choice for households with trades, dog walkers, or family coming and going.
Go Keyless
The most durable fix is to remove the spare-key problem entirely with a smart lock installation, which lets you grant temporary or permanent codes instead of handing out metal keys, and you can revoke access the moment you no longer want someone to have it. No key means nothing to find, nothing to lose, and nothing to copy.
When a Spare Key Goes Missing
If a spare disappears and you cannot account for it, treat it as a security event rather than a minor annoyance. You do not know who has it or whether it was copied. The responsible move is to rekey the locks it opened, which makes the missing key useless without replacing the entire lock. Rekeying changes the internal pins so the old key no longer works, and it is a routine job.
A Few Good Habits
- Keep track of how many spares exist and who holds each one.
- Collect keys back from anyone who no longer needs access, such as former housemates or ex-partners.
- Rekey after moving into a previously owned home, since you cannot know how many copies are out there.
- Avoid labelling keys with your address or anything that identifies the lock they open.
Build It Into Your Overall Home Security
Spare-key management is one piece of a larger picture that includes your deadbolts, door hardware, and entry points. If you are rethinking how people get into your home, it is worth doing it comprehensively. A conversation with a provider offering residential locksmith services can cover your spare-key strategy alongside the locks themselves, so access to your home is something you actually control rather than something you hope nobody stumbles onto. That is the practical, whole-picture approach Locksmith On Time takes with Ottawa homeowners.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where is the safest place to keep a spare key?
Not outdoors. The safest options are leaving it with a trusted person, using a tamper-resistant lockbox with a code you control, or going keyless so there is no physical spare to find at all.
Are fake rocks and hidden-key products safe?
No. They are so widely sold that they are instantly recognizable and often stand out in a yard. Anyone looking for a hidden key checks for them first.
What should I do if I lose a spare key?
Treat it as a security event. Because you cannot know who has it or whether it was copied, rekeying the affected locks is the responsible fix. It makes the lost key useless without replacing the whole lock.
Is a smart lock better than a spare key?
For many homeowners, yes. A smart lock lets you issue and revoke access codes instead of handing out physical keys, so there is nothing to lose, find, or copy, and you control who has access at any time.